Idol Update: 4
Girls night on Idol was brutal. Not so much because the performances were horrific (though they were pretty lackluster), but because the judge's comments were more visceral than critical. Even fan-favorite Ellen Degeneres did not hesitate to lampoon the conestants at every turn. That's not to say that the judges shouldn't be critical. But I fail to see how saying that any particular performance ruined their chances is constructive.
In any case, last night's standout was Siobhan Magnus. Watch below:
Comments
That being said, this girl was fantastic. The fact Simon calls her weird is the reason I have only seen one episode. I can't stand to watch a show that constantly tears down "weirdness," yet sees time after time that uniqueness actually wins out in the end (see Adam Lambert's success over what's his name with the guitar and anything with the name Clay Aiken in any sentence not containing Ruben Studdard).